
FSD
Home Page
Why
these Fire Safety Director pages were created
![]()
|
There can be no doubt that members
of the Fire Department of New York are truly
New York's Bravest. 343
members firefighters were lost (including numbers 2, 3, and 4 of the
top brass); they died when the buildings collapsed while they were
attempting to rescue victims and extinguish the fires. 147 promotions
were required to fill the command ranks to replace those who died.
Our thoughts and prayers go out to them, their families, friends, and
their fellow fire fighters who are digging through the rubble seeking
additional victims. | |
|
Six fire safety directors and deputy
fire safety directors lost their lives on Sept. 11, 2001. Their
names are Larry Boisseau, James Corrigan, Richard Fitzsimons, Philip Hayes,
Robert Mayo and William Wren. Our thoughts and prayers go out to their
families and friends. |
|
The World Trade Center was constructed differently from other buildings.
|
|
Preliminary reports show different causes of collapse for the two buildings:
| |||||||||||||
|
A February, 2004 PBS Innovations telecast on engineering extremely tall skyscrapers provided a slightly different scenario of the WTC collapses:
| |||||||||||||
|
Items which should be addressed in future standards of building construction:
|
Changes were proposed at a conference in June, 2002
Whether any of these proposals will ever go
into effect is unknown. | ||||||||||||||||
|
Evacuating the fire floor and the floor above are correct under ordinary circumstances. You were taught that in the event of a fire you evacuate the fire floor and the floor above; other building occupants remain where they are. This is to prevent clogging the fire stairs with individuals who should not be at risk, and allow firefighters to use the stairs to gain access to the fire floors. This could not take into account the unique situation at the WTC, since suicidal peacetime air attacks on buildings had never happened before. Newsday (Sept. 13, 2001 page W11) reported that after the first plane hit building one, an announcement was made that "Building One is in a state of emergency, Building Two is secure. You're fine, you can return to your work stations." In retrospect it was a terrible announcement, because people remained in Building Two and were killed or trapped when the second plane hit that building, but it was the right instruction to make at that time. Evacuating Building Two at that time would have exposed evacuees to debris falling from Building One, and clogged the surrounding area, making it difficult for firefighters to get to the scene. They were safer in the building than outside, and would have been fine if the second plane had not hit that building. Of course if you're the FSD, it's your choice on whether or not to evacuate. In a building which has been attacked in some fashion (airplane, bomb, etc.), you can certainly order a complete evacuation, especially if done in a manner which won't cause panic. Unless the FDNY changes their FSD test to cover such extraordinary circumstances, the answer is "evacuate only the fire floor and the floor above." |
![]()
FSD
Home Page
Why
these Fire Safety Director pages were created
Copyright © 2000-04, Ralph G. Johnson. All rights reserved.